It did have some moments in the middle that seemed a little of course to the topic but I guess it was there to add validity to the history of the myth of homework. Kohn comes from far left of center in his writing about education. Are certain kinds better than others? While I didn’t agree with all of his interpretations and recommendations, I found a lot of what he said convincing. Kohn then proceeds to suggest throughout the book that maybe The book offers insightful questions that parents, students and educators should be asking in regards to homework. Saying that this book definitely has it’s merits. Anyway, you can skip over the more research oriented sections if you aren’t as interested in that part.

Too many fifth graders have to color in an endless list of factor pairs on graph paper. Whether it was being done? This book shines a light on the many negatives associated with HW including widening the already too wide achievement gap and the irrational ways we justify it preparing them for What are its other effects on their lives, and on their families? She once came over the loudspeaker to threaten teachers because she’d heard a rumor that teachers weren’t assigning HW everyday. Other countries give lots of homework and we need to catch up to them.

A no mythh policy is a challenge to me,” he adds. Kids should be kids, yes, but homework is part of ensuring that learning continues after the classroom door closes; furthermore, in some cases, it can actually keep kids as kids, giving them Alfie Kohn should look up rhetorical appeals before he writes another book– namely, he should have more recent evidence, as well as case studies from fictitious families. His inclusion of some weaker arguments in the text also do not do justice to the subject.

the homework myth alfie kohn 2006

She once came over the loudspeaker to threaten teachers because she’d heard a rumor that teachers weren’t assigning HW everyday. And I certainly notice a large correlation between students who come from backgrounds with extensive homework policies and those who do not. There’s a lot of research out there suggesting that homewor After reading Love in the Time of Homeschooling by Laura Brodie, I wanted to read some books about homework.


But in chapter 4 skeptically titled “‘Studies Show There is a difference between what teachers want to teach and what kids actually learn. One cannot help but conclude that one day in the future people will look back in marvel at the pain and suffering adults and society put children through in the name of “education” and “well-being”.

When students not assigned homework they choose their own activities, which are meaningful to them.

the homework myth alfie kohn 2006

The results are nothing homewokr of stunning. But when the learning is meaningful we learn much faster. I began teaching in Baltimore and the principal mandated that we assign homework everyday.

The Homework Myth: Why Our Kids Get Too Much of a Bad Thing

I don’t give much homework, but that is because I don’t believe in busy work; however, I should have given more independent practice this past year, and that’s something I intend to rectify next year. Have homeowrk respect and involve them in discussions and decisions about their own lives. The reason I am depressed, though, is because I don’t see an easy way out.

Apr 18, Kristen rated it really liked it. I do, however, plan on asking a homewirk questions at parent-teacher conference about the kinds of homework I’m seeing in Cameron’s backpack.

Students could spend every waking hour filling out worksheets or studying for tests, but it still wouldn’t result in the creation of more or better, or higher-paying jobs wherever they happen to live, nor would it appreciably affect interest rates, the demand for professionals versus service workers, the degree to which market power is concentrated in the hands of a few giant conglomerates, or almost any other economic variable” In my mind, that is a big endorsement for Kohn’s ideas on homework.


Some seem to lack the basic skills necessary to survive in a prep school environment. This gets old by half way through the book. When do we sit down and actually think, well what is the point of homework and why do we assign it?

Just because we did it doesn’t make it good for students, especially since younger and younger students are being assigned more and more work.

Find out what students think of homework and solicit their suggestions — perhaps by distributing anonymous questionnaires. Reading the book left me angry with how seemingly no child is left behind from the clutches of the “homework machine” It teaches you how to do work for when you are in high school kohb college. Anyway, you can skip over the more research oriented sections if homewrok aren’t as interested in that part.

Rethinking Homework – Alfie Kohn

But there isn’t enough time to do all that practice and cover the content. Anecdotal reports abound of five- si- and seven-year-olds bursting into tears or vomiting in terror, their incipient self-confidence dissolving along with their composure. It’s really teh for a life spent working in corporations. Sep 22, Jerrod Griebel rated it it was ok.

The Homework Myth:

This one leans a little heavy on the elementary level, and I’m more concerned with secondary. Dec 29, Amy rated it it was amazing Shelves: None of these assumptions, he shows, actually passes the test of research, logic, or experience. First, he states that we should reset the default so that homework isn’t a given.

Back to Top